Sauce for the Goose
September 29, 2010 Leave a comment
You probably know the saying, “What’s sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.” It flies in the face of double standards. It says that if you can do something, so can I. Conversely, if some consequence for bad behavior for you is fitting, then the same consequence is fitting for me if I do the same thing. Everybody plays by the same rules. It’s the antithesis of means testing. Let’s look at this with a bit of retrospective regarding last year’s failed Swine Flu (H1N1) pandemic. Please don’t get me wrong. My heart goes out to all the families who lost loved ones due to the disease. My criticism is with its handling.
States do means testing for their benefits and tax policies. Hospitals do means testing for how much they charge their patients. Rich patients or those with insurance pay more than poor patients with no insurance. State-run clinics means test for how much patients pay for their services. Means testing determines Medicare coverage. Means testing determines how much of your Social Security income is taxed. Means testing is a way to regulate the supply or cost of a good or service by manipulating the price paid by the consumer.
Businesses don’t do means testing but they do practice supply and demand. The price of oil goes up therefore making gas more expensive. Some people modify their driving habits to use less gas and thus not spend as much. If things cost more then either you spend more or you cut down on your consumption.
Means testing is as well ingrained in the health care industry as supply and demand is in the rest of the capitalist system. So why are states upset when pharmacies vary their charges for Swine Flu or other vaccines? Some claim price gouging such as what happens when stores jack up the price of water after a hurricane cripples the water supply of a town or region.
The problem? There were claims this last flu season that the varying cost of Swine Flu vaccine from state to state and within a state, sometimes by as much as $75 across the state, was price gouging. Ignore the fact that some pharmacies have to mix their own formula for children’s doses (ever hear of increased labor costs? Ever hear of malpractice insurance? Someone has to pay for them to take the risk of mixing the vaccine themselves.) Ignore the fact that the vaccine itself was in short supply in some places. One place charged $49 and another charged over $90 for the same dose. Often these were in the same area and it was relatively easy to get from one place to another.
The solution? Chris Dodd, retiring Democrat Senator from Connecticut, wanted a government investigation and the Mississippi State Attorney wanted people to report any price gouging they found. Of course this begs a very important question. What is price gouging here? If the drug store I visit charges $90 I should report them, right? Forget the fact that I can go to another pharmacy across town and pay only $49. The government needs to do something for me because I’m too lazy to shop around! His committee investigation should have its results about a year and a half after the Swine flu has long subsided and the next flu season that’s coming kicks in so don’t hold your breath for meaningful results. Perhaps they’ll have something before the next manufactured “crisis”.
I don’t know what Dodd’s committee intends to accomplish. Maybe he’s jealous over the competition for medical care dollars. Maybe he’s looking for ways to get pointers on how to ration health care under the guise of caring what happens to you. Maybe it’s good that he’s retiring.
I don’t see how the variation in prices for H1N1 vaccine was price gouging but then again, I’m not a government hack, so what do I know? It’s supply and demand. You want what I have, here’s the price. If enough people refuse to pay the price and go somewhere else, maybe I’ll consider lowering my price before the vaccine I’m holding goes bad or isn’t needed.
Don’t like the price, maybe WalMart has a better price. Not everyone advertises “Always low prices … Always” (or at least used to.) Use your phone and call around. By the way, at what price is it gouging? Who sets the standard? Maybe we need to fix the price and be done with it. Hmmm… Sounds like socialized medicine is one more step closer. The current year’s flu vaccine is currently about $25 at my local food store pharmacies.
What do you think ObamaCare will do? Means testing is the centerpiece of government programs. Government bureaucrats, not your doctor, will regulate how much health care you can get. They will limit the supply regardless of the demand. They will limit it depending on your income, age, and current health. Ignore the fact that health care is nowhere mentioned in the Constitution as a federal responsibility. They will control your access to health care and you will lose your freedom of choice about it. Get used to it. It’s coming.
People look to the UK for the model of government- run health care. The claim is that it is second to none, and it is … when you can get it. The trick over there is convincing the government that you truly are worthy of being treated for your ailment. The same will be true here.
Socialized medicine only works when the government has enough of your money to spend freely. As the amount of your money decreases, so does the quality of the health care they’ll allow you to receive.
I can hear the campaign slogans in the New World Order: Want a vaccine? Then vote for me! I’ll make sure you get it or die trying.



























































